“To keep the air he breathes as pure as the external air, without chilling him.”
Florence Nightingale, founder of modern nursing and an early advocate of ventilation in hospital design, from Notes on Nursing (1859)
On the evening of March 10, 2020, sixty-one members of a community choir in Skagit County, Washington, gathered in a large multipurpose room for their usual two-and-a-half-hour Tuesday rehearsal. One of them had what felt like a cold. Within days, 52 of the other 60 people in that room were sick, three were hospitalized, and two died, according to the investigation the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention published that May. Nobody in the room touched anyone else, and many skipped the snacks. What they shared was the air. Six years later, that rehearsal remains a widely cited case in a quiet but real shift in how buildings are designed, and church ventilation and indoor air quality are moving from a mechanical afterthought to a decision that belongs in the earliest conversations about a new sanctuary, fellowship hall, or children’s wing.
The shift is easy to miss because it did not arrive as a new law. It arrived as a new standard, a body of research, and a slowly changing set of expectations among engineers, health officials, and the people who sit in the pews. For the congregations and nonprofits we work with, the practical question is not whether to panic about air. It is whether the building you are about to spend millions on will be able to do something its predecessors could not: change how it breathes when the situation calls for it.
From the research
“The act of singing, itself, might have contributed to transmission through emission of aerosols, which is affected by loudness of vocalization.”
What church ventilation codes were written to do
Most owners assume the ventilation requirements in their building code were set with health in mind. They were, but only in a narrow sense. The reference standard behind most commercial ventilation design, ASHRAE Standard 62.1, sets minimum outdoor air rates intended to keep a space acceptable to the people in it: odors controlled, carbon dioxide from breathing kept in check, contaminants from building materials diluted. For a place of religious worship at the standard’s default density, that works out to roughly five and a half cubic feet per minute of outdoor air per person. That is a reasonable number for comfort. It was never derived from a model of how a respiratory virus moves through a room full of people singing.
That gap is what ASHRAE set out to address in 2023 with Standard 241, Control of Infectious Aerosols. The standard was developed unusually fast. Benjamin Jones of the University of Nottingham, who co-led its risk modeling, has described how the White House COVID-19 Response Team requested it and how the committee completed a final draft in 108 days, a process that normally takes years. Rather than raising everyday ventilation rates, Standard 241 introduces what it calls Infection Risk Management Mode: a defined operating state that a building switches into when local health conditions warrant, with a target amount of “equivalent clean air” delivered per person. The word equivalent matters. Clean air under 241 can come from outdoor air, from filtration of recirculated air, from portable or in-duct air cleaners, or from germicidal ultraviolet systems, in whatever combination the building can manage.
Put those two figures side by side and the scale of the change becomes clear. A sanctuary designed to the ventilation code delivers on the order of five or six cubic feet per minute of outdoor air per occupant. Standard 241 asks for about nine times that much clean air per person when the building is in its risk management mode. No reasonable engineer would try to close that gap with outdoor air alone in a Missouri August, where every additional cubic foot of humid outside air has to be cooled and dried before it reaches the room. The gap gets closed, if it gets closed at all, with a mix of better filtration, air cleaning, and, as the standard’s own authors point out, fewer people in the room.
Why worship spaces sit at the far end of the curve
Places of worship are not a random entry in this conversation. They are one of the spaces where the distance between everyday ventilation and infection control is widest. In his 2024 summary of the risk modeling behind Standard 241, Jones lists healthcare waiting rooms, lecture halls, and places of worship as the categories least protected by the 62.1 minimums, and notes that reducing occupancy may be the easiest way to increase clean air per person in them. The reasons are familiar to anyone who has led a congregation. Sanctuaries pack people densely, often at the code’s eighteen inches of pew per person. Services run an hour or more. People sing, and as the Skagit investigators noted, aerosol emission rises with the loudness of the voice. And a meaningful share of the people in the room are older, which raises the stakes of every infection.
There is an honest counterweight, and it comes from the same body of research. In an October 2023 ASHRAE Journal column, Richard Bruns of the Johns Hopkins Center for Health Security ran a cost-benefit analysis of operating each space type in Standard 241’s risk management mode for sixteen winter weeks a year. For a model worship space of 2,000 square feet holding 180 people, he estimated roughly 4.8 infections prevented per year, worth about $9,000 by the federal government’s methods for valuing health outcomes, against an annual cost of about $8,700. That is close to break-even. A gym in the same analysis came out at $72,000 in benefit against $11,000 in cost. The difference is hours of use. A sanctuary filled twice on Sunday and once on Wednesday simply has fewer occupied hours over which to spread the cost of the equipment. Bruns also cautions that his cost assumption of about a dollar per year for each added cubic foot per minute of clean air is probably high, particularly for infrequently used spaces.
That finding is useful precisely because it is unflattering. It tells a church that the strongest case for investing in cleaner air is often not the main worship room at all. It is the rooms used every day: the weekday preschool, the counseling suite, the office wing, the fellowship hall that doubles as a community meal site. It also tells a church that the cheapest risk control in a sanctuary may be operational rather than mechanical, such as spreading a large Easter crowd across an extra service, opening the overflow room, or using the balcony that has sat empty for years.
The building does not need to run in its most protective mode all the time; it needs to be able to get there without a construction project.
What this trend changes in the design of a new church
The practical lesson we draw from all of this is that indoor air quality in churches is becoming a question of capability rather than constant operation. The building does not need to run in its most protective mode all the time; it needs to be able to get there without a construction project. That is a design problem, and it is far cheaper to solve on paper during schematic design than to retrofit after the ceilings are closed. Several decisions carry most of the weight. Air handling units and ductwork can be selected with enough fan capacity and filter rack depth to accept higher-efficiency filters, which resist airflow more than the basic filters most systems ship with. Ceiling layouts can reserve locations and power for in-room air cleaners or upper-room ultraviolet fixtures, so that adding them later means mounting a device rather than running new circuits through a finished sanctuary. Mechanical rooms can be sized for the larger equipment rather than squeezed to the minimum.
Zoning matters as much as capacity. A church campus is not one space but many, used on very different schedules, and the rooms with the highest risk are often not the biggest. The Skagit outbreak happened in a rehearsal room, not a sanctuary. Choir rooms, youth rooms, and nurseries benefit from their own air handling, or at least their own controllable zones, so that a congregation can step up clean air delivery where people are singing, crowded, or most vulnerable without paying to condition the entire building at that rate. The same logic favors separating weekday-occupied wings from the worship room, which also happens to make operational sense for energy use. We wrote about how worship rooms are now being programmed around hours of weekly use rather than peak seat count, and air handling is one of the places where that thinking pays off most directly.
Monitoring is the quieter half of the trend. Carbon dioxide sensors in occupied rooms are inexpensive and give facilities staff a real-time proxy for whether outdoor air is keeping up with the people in the room, which is useful information whether or not anyone ever invokes Standard 241. They do not measure the benefit of filtration or air cleaning, so they are an indicator rather than a verdict, but a building that reports how it is performing gives the next facilities manager something better to work from than a guess. Monitoring also feeds the energy conversation. Outdoor air is one of the largest loads a mechanical system handles in a humid climate, and the shift toward all-electric buildings that we discussed in our look at heat pumps and the gas line decision makes it more important, not less, to bring in outside air when it is needed and not when it is not.
Infection is not the only reason this capability is gaining ground. In 2024 ASHRAE published Guideline 44, which addresses protecting building occupants from smoke during wildfire and prescribed burn events, and the same features that let a building step up filtration for a virus season let it hold its air steady on a smoke day. The two documents are increasingly discussed together. In 2026 the Toronto Board of Health asked the Province of Ontario to incorporate both Standard 241 and Guideline 44-2024 into the Ontario Building Code, and on August 19, 2026, ASHRAE’s president wrote to Ontario’s housing minister urging the province to do so. None of this changes what a church in southwest Missouri is legally required to build today. It does show the direction health officials and the engineering profession are moving, and buildings last long enough to meet the expectations of the decade after they open.
Where the evidence is thin, and why that matters for your budget
It would be a disservice to present any of this as settled science, and the people who wrote the standard are the first to say so. In the same 2024 presentation, Jones cited a Royal Society review that started with roughly 14,000 papers on non-pharmaceutical interventions and found 19 peer-reviewed studies on environmental measures such as ventilation and air cleaning worth assessing, every one of them rated low confidence because of confounding factors. He described the Standard 241 clean air targets as indicative rather than exact, and acknowledged that a different committee could have reached a different consensus. The underlying physics, that more clean air per person lowers the concentration of whatever people are breathing out, is not in dispute. The precise number that makes a room safe is.
For an owner, that uncertainty argues for a measured response rather than an expensive one. We would not advise a congregation to size an entire sanctuary system to run continuously at 50 cubic feet per minute of clean air per person; the first cost, the energy bill, and the noise from the added airflow would all be real, and the benefit, by the best available analysis, roughly matches the cost. We would advise building in the ability to get closer to that target when it matters, focusing the strongest measures on the rooms used most often and by the most vulnerable people, and giving facilities staff the controls and information to use what has been built. That approach costs comparatively little when it is decided early, and it avoids the worst outcome, which is a new building that cannot respond at all.
Nightingale argued for fresh air in hospital wards long before anyone could name the organisms she was fighting, and she paired that argument with a caution about not chilling the patient. The modern version of her point is much the same: deliver clean air where and when it matters, without making the building uncomfortable or unaffordable to run. The tools for doing that are better than they have ever been. The decision to make room for them, literally and financially, still has to be made by someone before the drawings are finished.
At UNITE, mechanical strategy is part of how we program a church from the first meeting, not a system we hand to an engineer after the floor plan is set. Our work on more than a thousand church projects has taught us how congregations actually use their buildings across a week, which rooms fill on a Wednesday night, where the choir rehearses, and which wing a weekday preschool will occupy, and that knowledge is exactly what determines where cleaner air earns its cost. We bring those questions to the table early, with options that fit the budget rather than a single expensive answer, so that the building you open can adapt to the years it will serve. If you are planning a new sanctuary, an education wing, or a renovation of a building your congregation has outgrown, we would be glad to talk through what the air in it should be able to do.
Let’s Talk About Your Project
Every project starts with a conversation. If you have something in mind, or just a question, reach out and we will get back to you within one business day.